Archive for the ‘Joaquim Carvalho’ Category

FIH conspired to keep India out of Olympics

March 14, 2008

According to Carvalho, the Coach of the Indian Hockey Team, FIH has conspired to ensure that India did not qualify for the Olympics. As I read through what he has written, I do feel that he has some very valid points.

How was the Tournament Director allowed to wake up Indian Players before the match and chide them for playing in the harms way. That is something really astonishing as none of the video’s suggested any foul play nor did the Referee call for a foul.

Read the article

It was a painful home-coming for the team and I feel sorry for the boys. The team’s failure to qualify for the Olympics evoked strong reactions in the country and it is now very important to support the players in these difficult times.

The last few days have given me the time to ponder about what went wrong in Santiago and I feel that we could have still made it to the Beijing Olympics if the umpiring was not biased against us.

We were just not allowed to play our natural game in the final match against Great Britain by the umpires and the Tournament Director. There was a discreet conspiracy by the FIH and Great Britain.

In our league match against Great Britain, we received two yellow cards. Our boys were pulled up without reason and these cards were not warranted. But the British were getting away scot-free.

Tushar Khandekar was hooked in the penalty area and was floored. No stroke was given, which we deserved. Vikram Khan getting a yellow card was justified. But the British player, who was also involved in the incident, was given a warning.

Shivendra Singh was given a yellow card when he slipped over there. The British player had hooked Shivendra and no penalty was awarded or a card given to him.

The incident was viewed on the video after the match and the umpire’s blunder was accepted by the Tournament Director. But then, India paid a heavy price for these lapses.

After the league match against Britain, the tournament director called our manager and the three Indian players at the ground. They offered to show the video clippings that our players had indulged in fouls.

The same night, the boys were called from their rooms at 11.00 pm and given a letter saying that “This is not the way you all should be playing. You are all international players. How can you play like this and we are warning you. You all will be severely pulled up in the final match.”

They literally psyched out our main players. Why did they call Gurbaz Singh when he had not received a yellow card at all? It was just to put us under pressure ahead of such a crucial match.

Our boys had mentally lost the game even before going onto the field. They were totally shattered. Gurbaz and other players were asking me as to how they can go for a tackle when they were sure that they will be given yellow cards and suspensions.

People concerned in FIH require their privacy and do not want to be disturbed. It is also a mystery to me as to how the hotel management allowed international players disturbed at the dead of the night. I believe there are some new rules brought in by the FIH.

The Tournament Director applied pressure on our boys under the pretext of a complaint by the British coach for intentional fouls by our players. The video replay showed that Gurbaz had not touched any player. The umpire also did not warn Gurbaz. How can the tournament director issue Gurbaz such a severe letter?

When I queried they said this is something new that the FIH has started recently. But, can they come at 11 in the night?

I also read some articles where Ric Charlesworth said that I was keen to keep him away from the team and that I was responsible for preventing him from going to Chile. Charlesworth had said that if he had come to Santiago, India would have qualified.

It is very surprising as Charlesworth had earlier said that it will take India five years to get to the top. Could he do it in one day?

Secondly, in Chile, Bob Davidson of the FIH called me up and said Ric was waiting in Perth. The Indian government and SAI had told him that if I wanted, Charlesworth will be in Chile.

I told Davidson “how can I answer this question of yours? Who am I to answer this question?”

When we went to Australia for a few exposure games, I was not even aware that he (Charlesworth) is coming to Perth. Before leaving India for Perth, I had acknowledged his efforts in arranging the tour. Nobody from the Government or SAI has advised me till now about Charlesworth’s involvement with the senior team. When did I say I don’t want Charlesworth?

I think it is time that we compare these incidents to what happened to our cricket players in Australia recently. The umpires killed our Test team in Australia. The Indian Cricket Board and the media supported them fully. Then, the ICC crumbled down.

Now, the same thing should be done instead of criticising the Indian hockey players. In this case, the Indian people and the media should have supported the players. We should compare as to what generally happens to our cricket teams on their tours to Australia and England.

Were there any instances of a cricketer being called from his room to the lobby at the dead of the night and reprimanded by the Match Referee? This does not happen and should not happen even in future to any sportsperson in the world. Definitely, our boys were under pressure.

When I announced that I will quit, the boys were so upset that they all came to me and pleaded to me that I should not quit. They all said we do not want anybody to come and spoil the composition of the team built all these 10 months. It is just one bad match that we played. They said that if I quit they will be totally shattered and they do not want to continue.

I am going to mention all these in my report to the IHF, which goes to the SAI and the Sports Ministry also.

The FIH did not post neutral umpires as has been the practice in such tournaments. When they had a European and a South African to officiate in our final match, why they did not have an Asian to officiate with the European or South Africans? They cannot because an Asian will not succumb to FIH to fix India.

http://sports.indiatimes.com/FIH_conspired_against_India_Carvalho/articleshow/2865030.cms

Performances of the Indian Hockey Team over the years

March 13, 2008

The Indian hockey team was crushed by Great Britain and wiped out by China in the Doha Asiads and and repeatedly defeated by arch rivals Pakistan.

If you take the big picture of Indian hockey in the last decade the debacle in Santiago, where it lost to Great Britain, was just waiting to happen.

This is how we have moved:

Year—Olympic Venue——–India’s Rank

1984—-Los Angeles———–5th

1988—-Seoul——————6th

1992—-Barcelona————-7th

1996—-Atlanta—————-9th

2000—-Sidney—————-7th

2004—-Athens—————-7th

So the homecoming of Indian hockey after the disgraceful exit from Olympics might have inspired shock but not surprise.

The coach has stepped down after the latest debacle saying factors beyond performance had played a role in the Santiago debacle.

“We didn’t play to our potential and I think, it was one of the reasons, we were not able to play and as a result lost the match. The other thing is one is not being able to play and one is not being allowed to play,” said Joaquim Carvalho, former India Hockey Coach.

“I am not giving any lame excuses, but I felt and so did all the boys that the cards that were given in the two matches especially with Great Britain, in both the matches were forced to play with 10 players for nearly 25 minutes for cards which were not deserving,” Carvalho added.

Carvalho further said: “Some of the players who were not even given the card were called and issued letters after the match. Nowhere in international hockey can you warn a player that without even earning a card in the previous match, that if you do this, you will be pulled up. So definitely, the player will be under pressure.”

Joaquim Carvalho has cited reasons on the ground that led to the defeat, factors that an experienced hand could have helped handle.

But someone like celebrated coach Ric Charlesworth, our Technical Director was not given a ticket to fly down to Santiago with the team.

IHF: High-handed?

This is not the only instance of the Indian Hockey Federations’ myopic high-handedness.

In 1998 when India won the Asiads Gold after 32 years, the IHF dropped six star players including Dhanraj Pillai because they had made demands it did not agree with.

In fact, during the first 10 years of KPS Gill’s tenure as IHF head over 150 players and more than 15 coaches were replaced, giving the national team little sense of stability.

2003 saw some hopes of a turnaround with a win in the Asia Cup but it was victory that could not be sustained. And even in 2004 Athens Olympics when we lost to a mediocre Chinese team, IHF did not see it as cause for alarm.

If failing to qualify for the Olympics for the first time in 80 years wasn’t bad enough, Indian hockey has now been dealt another massive body blow by the International Hockey Federation (FIH), who are now threatening to relocate the 2010 Men’s World Cup which has provisionally been awarded to Delhi.

Change in world cup venue?

In an official statement, their president Els van Breda Vriesman said:

”The FIH will meet on March 25 to discuss further steps to be taken on continuing the project ‘Promoting Indian Hockey’ and to decide whether to stage the 2010 Men’s World Cup in New Delhi. It has already made it clear that the staging of the world cup is related to the success of the project. And the world body is still waiting for signs that things are really going to happen in India.”

It’s hard to argue with the FIH while it’s true that the men’s team has failed to qualify for the Olympics for the first time since 1928. It’s equally true that the team has failed to win an Olympic medal for 28 years now.

One major factor is poor infrastructure. Also, no incentives, not even when there are big wins like the 2006 Asia Cup.

The accolades and the prize money for the victory had paled in comparison to what the T20 Cricket World Cup players got.

“Currently we need to see how best we can improve the performance of the national team. Infrastructure does play a part and that would be more long-term in our plan. So both are equally important,” said M M Somaiyya, Technical Director, Indian Team.

“One is creating the infrastructure at the grass-root level so that we have a wider base to cast our net and the second we really need to look at the national team and see how best we can come back into the international tournaments ahead,” Somaiyya added.

And the icing on the cake is that the sports ministry has moved hockey, the national sport, from its priority list to the general list.

Which means the meagre money and attention that hockey used to get, even that will be hard to come by.

Gill wants rules to be changed for qualifying to Olympics

March 13, 2008

The Indian Hockey Federation (IHF) President KPS Gill has put the entire onus on the International Hockey Federation (FIH) for India’s failure to qualify for the Beijing Olympics.

Gill refused to blame the team’ performance for the loss in the qualifying tournament at Santiago in Chile that saw India losing out a spot in Olympics hockey for the first time in 80 years.

He also hinted at appointing a foreign coach to prepare for 2012 Olympic Games and said the present team has an excellent bunch of players and are doing fine.

Instead the IHF chief, who has been facing a lot of flak for India’s dismal performance, said that the FIH must chance the present system of qualification and added that the defeat should be taken positively as it gives the team time to prepare for the 2012 London Olympics with single-minded dedication.

Calling former players, who have been demanding more professionalism in the IHF and better training for the players, ‘professional mourners’, Gill ruled out that he had any plan to quit.

In fact former skipper Dhanraj Pillay and former goalkeeper AB Subaiah have called for the resignation of Gill after the debacle.

“It’s the worst day for Indian hockey. It’s time to replace the top officials of the federation. IHF never tried to take the help of players like me who have played for the country so long,” Pillay said after India lost in the qualifiers.

Gill also revealed that the resignation of chief hockey coach Joaquim Carvalho has not been accepted. Carvalho had quit after the Indian hockey team failed to qualify for the Olympics.

Carvalho will be meeting Gill on March 18 to discuss the Olympics qualifier debacle in detail.

However, he accepted the resignation of IHF vice-president Narender Batra.

http://www.ibnlive.com/news/gill-bypasses-olympic-debacle-aims-for-2012/61104-5.html


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.